Summary for flattened steel tube corrosion Discussion
Flattening the ends of steel tubes can create stress points that are more anodic than the unstressed metal, so they may corrode a bit more readily. In the thread’s quickstart answer, the advice is that phosphating usually neutralizes these hot spots enough that the issue is generally not serious. The key caution is that proper pretreatment is crucial for corrosion resistance: without phosphating, adhesion will suffer, the stressed areas can start to corrode, and underfilm corrosion may develop beneath paint or powder coating. The discussion is focused on mild steel tube ends that are cold formed or flattened before finishing, and it emphasizes that the corrosion risk is mainly a finishing/prep problem rather than an unavoidable failure if the steel is properly pretreated.
SUGGESTED PHOSPHATING BOOKS

“Optimization of Phosphating Process” by Vinod Prasad Sharma (2022)
avail from
<!–UTL eBay, –>
AbeBooks, or
Amazon

“Phosphating of Metals” by Werner Rausch (1991)
avail from
eBay,
AbeBooks, or
Amazon

“Phosphating & Metal Pretreatment” by D.B. Freeman (1986)
avail from
eBay,
AbeBooks, or
Amazon
(as an Amazon Associate & eBay Partner, we earn from qualifying purchases)
Quickstart:
Flattening or otherwise cold forming of steel introduces stresses, and stress points are anodic to non-stressed areas and will tend to sacrificially corrode, although phosphating will tend to neutralize these hot spots to the point where it is generally not a serious problem.
Proper pretreatment of steel is crucial to its corrosion resistance, and phosphating is the usual pretreatment. Without phosphating adhesion will suffer, these anodic hot spots will start to corrode, and underfilm corrosion (corrosion under the paint or powder coating) will develop.
SUGGESTED E-COATING, CED, E-PAINTING BOOKS
for Shops, Specifiers, & Engineers

“Electrocoat: Formulation & Technology” by Bruggemann & Rach (2020)
avail from
eBay,
AbeBooks, or
Amazon

“Electropainting: A survey of principles and practice” by Reginald Leslie Yeates (1980)
avail from
eBay,
AbeBooks, or
Amazon

“Electrophoretic Deposition (EPD)” by Nathan Bass (2017)
avail from
eBay,
AbeBooks, or
Amazon

“Electrocoating: a Guidebook for Finishers” by Electrocoat Association (2010)
avail from
AbeBooks, or
Amazon

“Handbook of Electropainting Technology” by W. Machu (1978)
avail from
eBay,
AbeBooks, or
Amazon
(as an Amazon Associate & eBay Partner, we earn from qualifying purchases)
Q. We are working with some tubular structure designs. I have been told that flattening ends of MS tubes which are then powder coated tends to have corrosion due to moisture having entry points at the ends of tube. We then get corrosion leeching out from the ends in (outdoor product) the rains making things ugly apart from the obvious corrosion. This is a consumer product so aesthetics are key factor. Our powder coats have a CED
⇦ huh? base.
Given that this is such a commonly used, cheap and effective way to make tubular products I was wondering what the general consensus in the industry is with this issue? ⇦ Answer?
Roy Allan
– UK
September 11, 2019
SUGGESTED POWDER COATING BOOKS
for Shops & Engineers

“Industrial Powder Coating: Basics, Methods, Practical Application” by Judith Pietschmann (2023)
avail from
eBay,
AbeBooks, or
Amazon

“User’s Guide to Powder Coating” by Nicolas Liberto (2003)
avail from
eBay,
AbeBooks, or
Amazon

“High Performance Powder Coating” by Bob Utech (2002)
avail from
eBay,
AbeBooks, or
Amazon

“Powder Coating. The Complete Finisher’s Handbook” by Nicolas Liberto (1994)
avail from
eBay,
AbeBooks, or
Amazon

“Powder Coating Systems” by William Lehr (1991)
avail from
eBay,
AbeBooks, or
Amazon

“The Technology of Powder Coatings” by S.T.Harris (1976)
avail from
<!–UTL eBay, –>
AbeBooks, or
Amazon
“Fundamentals of Powder Coating by Emory Miller & David Taft (1974)
avail from
<!–UTL eBay,–>
AbeBooks, or
Amazon
(as an Amazon Associate & eBay Partner, we earn from qualifying purchases)
A. Hi Roy. Moisture accumulation & entrapment are certainly a corrosion issue, and this is somewhat amplified by the fact that the stressed metal is anodic to the rest of the tube, tending to sacrificially corrode. I think the best answer (in addition to designs which discourage water from getting in and encourage it to get out) is proper zinc phosphatization, plus your e-coating before powder coating.
I bought a backyard gazebo/screen tent constructed with such flattened end tubing and it was rusting in under a week, so I appreciate the issue.
opinion! However, my strong suspicion is that no attention had been given to proper phosphate pretreatment — especially because there is zero environmental pressure towards sustainability and making metal fabrications durable, but enormous pennywise/pound foolish environmental pressure towards harassing finishing shops to reduce pretreatment chemical usage, and sabotaging their sustainability efforts.
If the tubes are immersion phosphatized (so there is some coverage on the I.D., e-coated, and powder coated, I think they will last a good while without corrosion.
Regards,

Ted Mooney, P.E. RET
Striving to live Aloha
finishing.com – Pine Beach, New Jersey
Need quick confidential answers? $25
Need project assistance? $100/hr.