Summary for home nickel plating Discussion
Home nickel plating with vinegar and salt is discussed as a low-risk way to demonstrate the concept, but the thread warns that it is unlikely to produce a durable, corrosion-resistant finish. The source notes that vinegar and salt may be fine for school experiments, yet users should practice on scrap rather than anything important. It also contrasts this with real nickel plating, which uses a Watts nickel bath with nickel sulphate, nickel chloride, boric acid, brighteners/wetters, and sulfurized nickel anodes. In the Q&A, Joe Hobbyist asks about plating the inside of a copper tube heat exchanger for pool-chemical corrosion protection, wondering whether pumping solution through it or filling it with centered nickel rods would work, and whether solder joints would be harmed. Another poster reports mixed results from a homemade nickel acetate bath: the first parts plated bright and smooth, but later parts turned dark, thick, uneven, gray, and peeling, suggesting bath chemistry or process control problems.
“Real” nickel plating is done with a Watts Nickel plating solution consisting of nickel sulphate, nickel chloride, boric acid, generic or proprietary brighteners & wetters, and sulfurized nickel anodes.
Q. I would like to try to “home” nickel plate the inside of a 100% copper tube heat exchanger for corrosion protection against pool chemicals, like Di-chlor. I was considering using a 5 gallon bucket and pumping the solution through the heat exchanger to accomplish this (assume 3 feet of non conductive hose in and 3 feet of hose out). There shouldn’t bee any air gaps, so the fluid should make one continuous electrical circuit. Will high flow inhibit the plating somehow? Or is it better to invert the heat exchanger, fill with solution and center nickel rods in the ends of the open pipe ends? Also, if the copper is soldered, will the plating process compromise the solder joints in any way?
Joe
Hobbyist at home. Engineer by trade. – Chicago
February 13, 2025
This is a meeting place for camaraderie & sharing, not a free consultancy. So some readers don’t engage with anonymous posters.
A. Hi Joe.
The plating shouldn’t hurt the solder but, if it’s older solder with lead, the plating won’t adhere to it because the usual acids will not dissolve the lead oxides on it — and plating needs to go onto raw metal not oxides for proper adhesion.
A bigger issue is that plating occurs in proportion to current density, per Faraday’s Law, but electricity takes the path of least resistance so you’ll get no plating except at the ends where your anodes are unless you manage to run a cathode wire all the way through the tube. Trying to do useful plating on your first attempt, and a difficult one at that, is bound to be a disappointment.
A basic point is that if you want to learn to electroplate as a hobby, go to it, but work on scrap until you’ve done significant learning. (If you’re truly serious about the art & science, a Hull Cell ⇦ huh?
is the way to learn, and it’s an actual tool that professionals use.)
Luck & Regards,

Ted Mooney, P.E. RET
Striving to live Aloha
finishing.com – Pine Beach, New Jersey
Need quick confidential answers? $25
Need project assistance? $100/hr.
Q. I tried to make a nickel sulphate solution and failed. I used 1 qt. distilled vinegar
⇦ in bulk on
or
Amazon [affil link] , added salts, put my pure nickel anode and cathode into the solution and ran a current through it until a light green color was achieved. My first two objects I plated were some iron parts for a slot machine. The were scrubbed, degreased and washed in distilled water before being put into the bath. I plated them for about 45 minutes in 400 ml of nickel acetate in a 500 ml beaker [beakers on
eBay
or
Amazon [affil link] at 10V 950 mA. They came out perfect. Bright, smooth and even.
The next three parts I plated (pretreated in the same method) the plating came out darker and darker. The last of the three resembling iron oxide (it was also very hard to polish off) Now the next batch I tried, I thought maybe I had the voltage too high so I dropped it to 5.5v 750ma and it came out even worse. The nickel plating was extremely thick, uneven, gray and peeling back in curls. Though underneath, it appeared to have a thin, bright layer.
Any help would be appreciated greatly!
Here’s the final results.

Randall Painter
– Ventura, California
August 7, 2020
“Nickel Plating”
by Robert Brugger

on
AbeBooks
<!–
or
–>
<!–UTL 5/3/2024
eBay
–>
or
Amazon (rarely)
(affil link)
A. Hi Randall. If you have control over the things you think you do, then the difference between your first run and your third is what you don’t have control over: the deterioration of your plating solution. So dispose of your old solution and make it up again or rejuvenate it.
The light green color hopefully means you have some nickel in solution … but it’s very little. Real nickel plating solutions are highly saturated deep emerald green. Your voltage is far higher than that low nickel concentration can sustain. Even 5.5 V is probably too high. I cannot explain satisfactory plating at 10 V in a very dilute nickel plating solution unless it is also low conductivity such that very little current is flowing. I can’t compute the current density you used with just the amperage without knowing the surface area.
Luck & Regards,

Ted Mooney, P.E. RET
Striving to live Aloha
finishing.com – Pine Beach, New Jersey
Need quick confidential answers? $25
Need project assistance? $100/hr.
Q. I would like to use this method to plate some skewers made of mild steel, would they be food safe after plating?
Thanks,
E Loewen
Retired but still curious – British Columbia
August 4, 2024
A. Hi E.
If well-rinsed, and if the plating adheres (which is not a sure thing), it would be food safe for skewers, although some people have a skin allergy to nickel. But I think you would be happier with stainless steel skewers.
I think it’s best to learn plating one step at a time through practice on scrap rather than trying to do functional plating on a food service item out of the gate. Good luck.
Regards,

Ted Mooney, P.E. RET
Striving to live Aloha
finishing.com – Pine Beach, New Jersey
Need quick confidential answers? $25
Need project assistance? $100/hr.


