Powder Coating - fail impact test (160 in-lbs) and Salt Fog Test 500hrs
April 16, 2008
I have problem to get my sample panel to pass the above requirement after powder coating.
Before coating we had applied required stages of pre-treatment including Zinc Phosphating. The base material used is GI (Galvanized Iron) without chromate. Impact test as per ASTM D2794 [link by ed. to spec at TechStreet]. Salt Fog test as per ASTM D1654 [link by ed. to spec at TechStreet], ASTM B117 [link by ed. to spec at TechStreet] and ASTM D610 [link by ed. to spec at TechStreet]. Please help me if you have any experience like this.
Nur - QA Engineer
fabrication and finishing - Malaysia
April 19, 2008
This reply is the same as my reply to another similar question on this forum.
Birmingham, United Kingdom
April 20, 2008
Assuming your pretreatment is good, have you checked the paint for proper cure? Contact your vendor for information about the overbake temperature and time. I've run into situations where parts were obviously clean and properly prepped before paint. We could easily scrape the paint off, and they'd fail in NSS in less than 48 hours. However, when we really baked the paint, it stuck like glue and the parts passed NSS without a problem.
- Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
June 11, 2008
For a powder to be perfect in all the sense, it should meet the following three criteria:
1. Good pretreatment of metal
- This as you mentioned, with zinc phosphating should take care. You can send some sample to labs analyzing Zn phosphate micron thickness coating.
2. Good curing
-Get to know from your supplier on what is the curing temp and time for this powder that you are using.
-Get your oven calibrated to show you the right temperatures.
3. %Resin in powder has to be optimum I guess it is somewhere around minimum of 70% for a good powder.
Lower the specific gravity, better is the powder.
- Ask your suppliers for %resins,plate test,sp. gravity specs and get the one with best cost and lesser sp. gravity,higher resins and higher value of plate test should help you to choose the right powder.
Check with your powder supplier on whether the tests you are doing are passing at their end or no. You may end up changing your powder.
All the best
- Old Goa, Goa, INDIA
July 4, 2008
Since your dealing with zinc phosphate, check and see if the phosphate coating is coming off with the paint. You may have poor rinsing prior to the phosphate application.Ron Zeeman
Coil Coating - Brampton, ON, Canada
April 29, 2012
Q. On a plate coated by a powder coating, what should be results of direct and indirect impact test for the electrical panels in normal conditions?Farshad Amini
consultant - Tehran, Iran
A. Hi cousin Farshad.
Your question is a bit out of my area of expertise, but based on the previous answers in this thread, I think you'll get better answers if you can explain the details of your situation. Thanks.
Ted Mooney, P.E.
Pine Beach, New Jersey
A. An extremely vague question.
Perhaps flesh the problem out a bit and someone may be able to assist.
Are you referring to reverse impact testing?
What material is the "electrical panel"?
What type & grade of powdercoating is applied?
What specification are you trying to achieve?
Trainer - Salamander Bay, Australia
May 23, 2012
Q. Hi, I am Farshad from Iran, working in an inspection company
in testing and inspection of carbon steel panels coated by epoxy polyester powder coating with specification of of 100 kg.cm. But our test fails at 20 kg.cm in direct impact and 5 kg.cm in reverse. Please help me to find the reason.
Thanks a lot
- Tehran, Iran
A. I would hazard a guess that you have a problem with cure.
It could be inadequate pre-treat but if it were I would expect a more consistent impact vs Reverse Impact failure.
I assume that you are following Powder Manufacturer's recommendations for cure time at metal temperature rather than at air temperature?
Maybe, if you could fully describe your process we could be of more help.
trainer - Soldiers Pt., Australia
August 7, 2018
Q. Impact test is not successful for 60 kg in powder coating of 2 mm thick MS crc material , the applied powder is str pp, microns is between 80-120. Kindly let me know the proper procedure to pass the impact testBalu J S
A. Hi Balu. There are a number of good suggestions on this page, which start from the assumption that the problem exists despite proper pretreatment since this is probably a more likely cause than poor powder coating. Is your pretreatment zinc phosphating? Thanks.
Ted Mooney, P.E. RET
Pine Beach, New Jersey
Striving to live "Aloha"
This public forum has 60,000 threads. If you have a question in mind which seems off topic to this thread, you might prefer to Search the Site