Discolorations on Inconel 718 -- Vacuum Furnace Discoloration?
A discussion started in 2004 but continuing through 20192004
Q. We vacuum braze and vacuum heat treat high temperature nickel based alloys. We perform frequent burnouts and perform weekly leak rates. We monitor argon quench gas for low dew points. Despite all our efforts to maintain sound vacuum systems, Inconel [Inco] 718 will frequently come out of heat treatments with blue to purple discoloration. Everyone outside of the furnace department swears we have a furnace problem but we know better. We have no ammunition to defend our position other than to show the heat treat cycle parameters and the furnace calibrations are within specification. Why is this material so susceptible to oxidation and what can we do to minimize the discoloration?Jim T [last name deleted for privacy by Editor]
aerospace repair engineer - Indianapolis, Indiana, USA
A. Try to do the following:
1) Check whether parts are clean prior to loading into furnace. A clean white rag soaked with Acetone [linked by editor to product info at Amazon] can be used for a solvent wipe test on the parts. Any indication of discoloration due presence of contaminants / black smut / oily layer require cleaning parts.
2) You can run one test piece of Inco 718 wrapped in 321 stainless steel foil. Leave a few holes so that vacuum can escape from the bag. Check whether you get good results.
3) Your vacuum furnace bake out cycle, TUS, SAT and calibration might be good. What about Leak Rate Test at Elevated Temperature, say at 1000 °F? Make sure your leak rate is no more than 15 mTorr/Hr.Bala [last name deleted for privacy by Editor]
aerospace - Winnipeg, Manitoba
A. The clean part is a must. Next, when is the last time you did a prescribed "oven burnout"?James Watts
- Navarre, Florida
2007 -- this entry appended to this thread by editor in lieu of spawning a duplicative thread
Q. We have heat treated Inconel [Inco] 718 tubing; three sets of tubing from three sources, all heat treated together. Upon return, one set of tubing is dark bluish to maroonish in color while the balance remain gray.
The tubes were formed and EBW [Electron Beam Welded] prior to heat treating and ultrasonically cleaned in a vapor degreaser using AK225 prior to being sent out for heat treat. All tubes looked similar in color prior to going out for heat treat.
Any assistance in determining the source of the color differences would be greatly appreciated.
Mfg. engineer - Redmond, Washington
A. Insufficient info. Some possibilities:
1) Pre-existing oxide affected subsequent oxidation during heat treatment.
2) Local differences in heat treat furnace atmosphere. The tubing nearest the oxygen leakage 'gettered' it from the atmosphere, turning dark blue while protecting the remaining tubes.
What was the initial condition of the purchased material, maybe solution annealed + water quenched? Perhaps some was also pickled + skin rolled.
What was the heat treatment after welding, maybe aging 8 hr at 1325 °F in ? atmospheres?
- Goleta, California
Finishing.com honored Ken for his countless carefully
researched responses. He passed away May 14, 2015.
Rest in peace, Ken. Thank you for your hard work
which the finishing world continues to benefit from.
Q. The .063" diameter tubing was purchased per the AMS5589 [link by ed. to spec at TechStreet] rev. D (Nickel Alloy, Corrosion and Heat Resistant, Seamless Tubing).
The specification calls for a solution heat treatment. Pickling, bright annealing, etc., are allowed, for surface finish effects.
Our receiving records only have the chemical composition of the material and that they were annealed the standard stated above. We do not know what other variants within the spec may have been applied to the tubing.
The tubes that were heat treated concurrently, were located within the same fixture, only a couple of inches apart.
- Redmond, Washington, USA
A. I don't have AMS5589 but note its title includes '1775 °F (968 °C) Solution Heat Treated.' Also, SAE shows that revision E (July 2007) eliminates the requirement for passivation after polishing. Does AMS5589D require polishing?
The proximity of the tubes within the furnace indicates a difference in material. The discoloration is almost certainly oxidation. The amount of oxidation depends upon the initial surface. Any residual high-temperature oxide [possibly (Ni,Fe)Cr2O4] will be less protective than an oxide (mostly Cr2O3) formed on a polished surface while aging at 1325 °F, and a polished + nitric acid passivated surface (enriched-Cr2O3) will be more protective.
It is possible to make some judgement regarding the presence and thickness of an oxide film using a passivation tester (basically, a VOM with a flat probe); see Letters 11772 "Testing for Passivation" and 33579 "Are passivation test kits gimmicks?".
If necessary to remove high temperature oxide, formulas for pickling Inconel alloys are given in 'Fabricating' available from Special Metals Corporation: www.specialmetals.com
Is your post-fabrication heat treatment merely the age-hardening (e.g., 8 hrs at 1325°F + 10 hours at 1150°F, often conducted in air) or the entire heat treatment [solutionizing (in protective atmosphere?), air cooling and aging]?
A brief article 'Heat Treating of Nickel and Nickel Alloys' is available at http://www.key-to-metals.com/Article32.htm
- Goleta, California
May 27, 2013
A. Some contaminants in a vacuum furnace come from sublimation of metals which coalesce onto the first cooler area of the furnace they meet which is usually a few layers into the hot face insulation or quench nozzles. Some of these metallics can be easily oxidized by water vapor even at room temperature. When the cycle is run the oxide is at a low enough temperature to be stable, but when the backfill and quench cycle occurs the heat is driven into the area where the oxide resides and some materials (such as manganese) will give up their oxygen and revert back too a lesser oxide or pure ... this free oxygen is then absorbed by the nearest getter which is usually the part.
A good way to test for this is to run samples with a preheat to around 1400 - 1500 °F for an hour - forced cool and then pump down without opening furnace, then proceed with your standard cycle.. This extra step forces any contaminant to release any retained oxygen which is then pumped out leaving a cleaner system for the actual process.
The only cure to this is a very, very intrusive rebuild of the hot zone ... all parts must be grit blasted clean or replaced and the vessel thoroughly cleaned, then a maximum temperature burnout after rebuild. You must also determine where the contaminant came from and either eliminate it from the run list or run with a partial pressure of at least 800 - 1000 mics (.8 - 1.0 T)
Vacuum Furnace Troubleshooting and Repair - Vernon, Connecticut, United States
October 25, 2017
Q. I have an Inconel 718 aircraft engine rotating part that is turning dark purple/blue following the vacuum age process. Other than it being a cosmetic issue, is there any reason I should be concerned about this discoloration?Alan Yost
- Havelock, North Carolina USA
Discoloring of Rene 125 during vacuum heat treatmentNovember 30, 2017
Rene 125 is a nickel based superalloy for turbine blades
Q. What can be reason for black surface of the part made from Rene 125 if heat department saying that vacuum process and furnace is OK? Parts are ultrasonic cleaned.Bedrich Dolezal
product designer - Prague, Czech Republic
March 11, 2019
Q. Jim, did you ever find out the exact cause of the discoloration? I have a similar case and know it is not the furnace.Rich Grossman
- Massachusetts, USA
Hi Rich. Jim's posting was from 2004; we are unable to reach him to alert him, and I doubt that he checks in frequently if at all. But if your problem is the same as his, the answers offered to him should have validity. Can you either try those suggestions or comment on them? Thanks.
Ted Mooney, P.E. RET
finishing.com - Pine Beach, New Jersey
Striving to live Aloha