Summary for specific certifications Discussion
problem with certifications specific to the drawing is the core issue Richard Webb raises: finishing vendors often default to certifying only against the purchase order, while the customer wants the certificate to name the actual process called out on the drawing. Blake Kneedler says this is a common customer-service frustration on both sides: suppliers can provide the paperwork requested, but only if the request is clear about what must be stated. He notes that some customers only want a “Certificate of Conformance” saying the order meets the PO, which he considers little more than a glorified packing list; in one case, he simply used the packing list with the certificate title and signature added. The practical takeaway is that a certificate is only useful if it explicitly identifies the required specification or process, but many customers are satisfied as long as the document is labeled “Certificate” and can be filed.
Q. I am having problems with certifications from finishing vendors. Some of them insist or default to certifying to my purchase order without noting the specification called out on the drawing. Certificate of Compliance is in the header. I maintain that this document does nothing more than what a packing slip does. When I ask for a certification it is because my customer wants a certification to a specific process and that process needs to be called out on the certification. Is this a problem for anyone else?
Richard Webb
QA Mgr – Lisle, Illinois
November 10, 2017
A. Richard,
I’m occasionally driven batty by customers that want a certificate of analysis, compliance, or whatever, but then aren’t happy with what I send them, yet have trouble expressing what they do want me to put on there.
It’s certainly good customer service to create whatever documentation the customer asks for, as long as the request is clear on what they need it to say.
One customer did tell me they just needed the “Certificate of Conformance” to state the order meets their purchase order, which as you said, seems little more than a glorified packing list. (In fact that’s exactly what I sent them, the packing list with “Certificate of Conformance” added at the top and my signature added at the bottom.) Don’t ask me why some people think that one more piece of paper, that doesn’t state anything new, makes any kind of difference.
Of course, many customers are happy with anything that says “Certificate” as the top so long as they have something to put in the file drawer.

Ray Kremer
Stellar Solutions, Inc.
![]()
McHenry, Illinois

November 10, 2017
A. Hello Richard,
In my experience, CoC is standard and readily accepted provided pn, po#, rev level are listed. Additional certifications are extraordinary or unusual. In case you need more than a very brief CoC, there are two options. You can make your own documents, even something like a checklist with multiple line items and initials required, and provide the document to the vendor whilst requiring the vendor to complete and return. Another option would be to write a short specification describing the documents sought, and refer to the new specification on po’s and drawings. Once the vendor knows what is required in terms of docs, after a short learning period, you may have smooth sailing.

Blake Kneedler
Feather Hollow Eng. – Stockton, California
December 26, 2017