Thermal-Only Metal Coloring: Strong Case Against 40 CFR 433

Summary for thermal-only metal coloring Discussion

thermal-only metal coloring is the core issue here: Jim Kirlin asks whether using dry heat, with or without a little steam, to give saw blades an aesthetic straw or black finish counts as “chemical metal coloring” under 40 CFR Part 433 and therefore makes the facility’s wastewater categorical. He notes that no wastewater is generated during the coloring step. James Watts responds that the regulator should cite the exact regulatory language and says he cannot see how the process would fit, adding that it is not a solid waste issue and that any concern might instead be air quality at the stack. Jim then clarifies that the dispute is specifically about wastewater under the Clean Water Act and asks for precedent showing thermal-only coloring qualifies as chemical metal coloring. The thread does not provide a definitive regulatory ruling or precedent, only skepticism from Watts and a request for citation-based support.

Q. A regulator has posed the question as to whether or not using dry heat or adding some steam during a final coloring process to saw blades to get an aesthetic straw or black look is considered “chemical metal coloring” in 40 CFR Part 433 which would then subject the facility’s wastewater as categorical. There is no wastewater generated in the thermal coloring process whether or not steam is used. Anyone run across this before?

Jim Kirlin
consultant – Greenville, South Carolina, USA
September 27, 2012


A. The bleep regulator should not be asking you. He should be quoting page paragraph and line number of the appropriate regs.
I cannot imagine how they could come up with that. By definition it is not a solid waste at least as I knew it.
They might be able to give you grief on air quality at the stack.

James Watts
– Navarre, Florida
September 28, 2012

Q. HI, thanks for you response. I may have left out some info that may be useful.
It’s not an issue of solid waste. 40 CFR Part 433 deals with wastewater under the Clean Water Act. The EPA has decided, but I do not think they completely understood the process having never laid eyes on it. I’m looking for a precedence where they determined that metal coloring through thermal techniques alone qualifies as “chemical metal coloring” as defined in the effluent guideline and the development document for the effluent guideline. Thanks.

Jim Kirlin
– Greenville, South Carolina, USA
October 2, 2012