Weld seam discoloration: important hot-dip galvanizing issue

Summary for weld seam discoloration Discussion

Color changes on weld seam of pipes during hot dip galvanizing were discussed as a likely coating-quality issue rather than a simple cosmetic one. The thread excerpt provided does not include the actual question or any named answers, so no specific diagnosis or remedy can be confirmed from the source shown. The only visible content is a promotional note for galvanizing books, including "Faults in Hot-Dip Galvanizing" by Dietrich Horstmann, suggesting the page is part of a technical archive on galvanizing defects. Because the substantive discussion is missing from the excerpt, the safest takeaway is that the page concerns discoloration at pipe weld seams after galvanizing, but the exact cause and recommended fix are not available in the supplied text.

SUGGESTED GALVANIZING BOOKS

for Engineers, Shops, Specifiers

galv_structures2016

“Hot Dip Galvanizing of Steel Structures” by Kuklik & Kudlacek (2016)
avail from
eBay,
AbeBooks, or
Amazon

Image related to Color changes on weld seam of pipes during hot dip galvanizing

“Handbook of Hot Dip Galvanization” by Maass & Peissker (2011)
avail from
eBay,
AbeBooks, or
Amazon

galv_and_concrete2004

“Galvanized Steel Reinforcement in Concrete” by Stephen Yeomans (2004)
avail from
eBay,
AbeBooks, or
Amazon

galv_practice_hornsby1995

“Hot Dip Galvanizing — A Guide to Process Selection & Galvanizing Practice” by M. J. Hornsby (1995)
avail from
eBay,
AbeBooks, or
Amazon

“Faults in Hot-Dip Galvanizing” by Dietrich Horstmann (in English, French & German)
avail from
Amazon

“User’s Guide to Hot Dip Galvanizing for Corrosion Protection in Atmospheric Service” by NACE (1997 only rarely avail.)
avail from
AbeBooks, or
Amazon

(as an Amazon Associate & eBay Partner, we earn from qualifying purchases)

Q. Hi,
We are faced with color changes on weld seam of hot dip galvanized ERW steel pipes DURING the STEAM BLOWING process (only outside surface). Pipe length is 6 meters. Coating thickness; 45-55 micron in the body of the pipe, 55-65 micron on the darkened weld seam. Can anyone help me to find the reasons of this problem?

56797

Regards,

Deniz Akin
Engineer – Istanbul, TURKEY
February 21, 2011

simultaneous replies February 24, 2011

A. Sir,

The weld wire is a more reactive steel than the strip from which the pipe is formed.

Regards,

Dr. Thomas H. Cook

Galvanizing Consultant – Hot Springs, South Dakota, USA

A. The seam weld has had the swarf removed by a scraping process which re-profiles the steel, which in turn allows faster alloying reaction in galvanizing. This means the composition of the coating at that point is higher iron alloy than surrounding area which has purer zinc on the surface of the coating.

The corrosion protection of the coating is proportional to the thickness of the coating not to the colour.

geoff_crowley
Geoff Crowley
Crithwood Ltd.
Westfield, Scotland, UK


crithwood logo

February 24, 2011

A. In ERW continuous pipemaking, there’s not usually any welding wire. The edges are continuously welded together by RF after being formed such that the two edges of the originally flat steel are now touching together at a point of the diameter of the tube. That weld often leaves a ridge, which is removed as the continuous tube moves along, by a stationary knife edge tool.
If it’s not sharp, that tool leaves a rough surface profile where the weld ridge was removed.

geoff_crowley
Geoff Crowley
Crithwood Ltd.
Westfield, Scotland, UK


crithwood logo

February 27, 2011


Q. Thank you for your reply Mr. Cook and Mr. Crowley.
Mr. Crowley, as you mentioned above, we do not use welding wire. We weld the edges together by high frequency resistance method. Then we remove the weld bead.

I removed the galvanize layer from the pipe surface by acid and couldn’t see any rough surface profile where the weld bead removed.

I understand that from your answer, there is no free zinc layer on the top of the coating where the problem reveals. So it seems dark-grey colored. I want to examine the coating layers under the microscope. Normally I have an etchant for galvanize layers but this time it did not work on this sample. Do you suggest any etchant solution to see clearly the galvanize layers under the microscope?

Regards,

Deniz Akin [returning]
– Istanbul, Turkey
March 30, 2011

A. Deniz,
I’m not sure how you could examine this weld area closely.
Have you measured the thickness of the galv layer on the weld (grey ) area versus the thickness of the other area? I suspect you might find it slightly thicker on average (over many measurements). This would tend to indicate alloying right through the thickness of the coating layer.

Another way to tackle this problem is with the customer. Why do they see this as a problem? The corrosion resistance of the grey is equal to the silver (providing similar thickness of coating). And all the coating will turn grey with time anyway, and so the grey stripe will disappear.
Is it just an appearance issue? Galvanizing doesn’t have a good reputation as an aesthetic coating, it’s a functional one.
Your coating (provided thickness of coating is OK over weld) meets the relevant standards, so what really is the problem?

geoff_crowley
Geoff Crowley
Crithwood Ltd.
Westfield, Scotland, UK


crithwood logo

March 30, 2011


Q. Deniz,
I wonder if you could let me know which etchant you were using for galvanize layers?
Indeed I need the solution!
Someone recommend 2% nital, do you think would it work?
Thanks in advance

Bekir Kilicaslan
– Hatay, Turkey
July 22, 2011


Galvanized pipe after hot dip is burned at the weld line.

Ta Van Thinh
– viet nam
September 23, 2020

? Hi cousin Ta. Please explain in what way you feel your problem is significantly different than the question asked by Bekir, or try to phrase your ongoing questions in terms of the detailed answers already offered. Or were you answering the question? Thanks!

Luck & Regards,

ted_yosem
Ted Mooney, P.E. RET
Striving to live Aloha

finishing.com – Pine Beach, New Jersey



Need quick confidential answers? $25
Need project assistance? $100/hr.

September 2020

none

adv.
this text gets replaced with bannerText

spacer gets replaced with bannerImages