Hydrofluoric / Nitric acid solution for pickling PH 15-7 Mo stainless steel
A discussion started in 2010 but continuing through 2019December 17, 2010
I need a pickling bath consisting of hydrofluoric acid and Nitric acid for PH 15-7 Mo steel. Do any of you have any experience with this solution for etching steel? I have done some experiments with the solution but have some problems with Intergranular Attack in my samples.
Hope you can help, Thanks
Engineer, Chemical - Grenaa, Denmark
First of two simultaneous responses -- December 22, 2010
The first question is why are you pickling this part?
Many years ago I tried to do some analysis on 718SS but was not good enough or did not have the right equipment to be able to positively find the depth.
Did some activation of 17-4PH without any long term problem, but the much higher Mo content will almost certainly drive the attack at the grain boundaries.
Just a wild guess, based on Ti that increasing the nitric:HF ratio will help some.
The most obvious is to reduce the time in the solution to an absolute minimum.
It will be interesting to see what the real metallurgists have to say.
- Navarre, Florida
Second of two simultaneous responses -- December 23, 2010
Can you explain your situation with a little more detail. At the moment all we have is an abstract idea of etching using a HF/Nitric acid solution.
What concentration limits are you using?
What are your pre-cleaning steps?
How much material are you trying to remove?
How long is your immersion time? Do you know how long the parts are in the bath before they start to show inter-granular attack?
Why are you etching? Is it to remove bulk material or to remove a contaminant such as heat treatment scale?
With this sort of information I'm sure someone can provide you with a solution to your problem.
Aerospace - Yeovil, Somerset, UK
December 23, 2010
A. Once you sort out what Brian said, remember that you will need to titrate for free fluoride. It is not terrible, but it takes a bit of learning and can be frustrating.James Watts
- Navarre, Florida
January 4, 2011
Q. Hi Brian,
Here are the answers to your questions:
- The concentration limits are not certain but the experiments I have made were done at a 1:10 ration for HF:HNO3 %vol. So I have tried different concentrations at this ratio.
- Pretreatment of the samples are cleaning in a Turco soap to insure that the samples are clean. A water break test is made to insure the test pieces are clean.
- The amount of material to be removed are 10 um
- The immersion time is being determined by an etch rate test of the bath.
- The etch is done as to prepare the parts for penetrant inspection.
Thanks for the responses.
Maintaining acid levels in Nitric-hydrofluoric pickling processApril 5, 2019
Q. We pickle 304 stainless in a solution that is Nitric and HF. Our targets are 15%-20% Nitric and 1%-8% HF.
We are looking to get control of the acid levels by type so that we can establish more consistent dunk times and plan more effectively. We currently measure and use Baumé to determine where the acid level is. From there we make additions of Ammonium Bifluoride and Nitric. The method for choosing how much is essentially undefined.
I am looking for a better measurement method and a scientifically grounded process for maintaining the acid levels.
- Seattle, Washington