Zinc bond strength: strong plating vs galvanizing answer

Summary for zinc bond strength Discussion

zinc bond strength is the core issue here, but the thread says the real answer is that both zinc electroplating and hot dip galvanising can provide outstanding adhesion when properly done. Prakash Shah asked which process gives more bonding strength on mild steel and why. The reply says that, on suitable substrates and with correct processing, neither process is inherently weak; any peeling usually points to a process problem such as inadequate cleaning or failure to remove scale, not a limitation of the coating method itself. The answer also cautions that the two processes are not always interchangeable because each has its own limitations and application constraints. The responder asks for more details, noting that an abstract comparison is hard to apply to a real job.

Quickstart: Both zinc electroplating and zinc galvanizing have outstanding bond strength; this theoretical question probably doesn’t truly address the poster’s actual problem, which we would guess is improper preparation resulting in poor adhesion.

Q. Generally we have two processes for applying zinc coating on mild steel jobs like 1, hot dip galvanising and 2, zinc electroplating.
in this regards I would like to know which process give more bonding strength and why .

pl respond

Prakash Shah
material manager – Ahmedabad, India
May 27, 2010

A. Hi, Prakash. Properly conducted on appropriate substrates, both processes exhibit plenty of bond strength for virtually any application. Any peeling indicates something wrong, not a weakness in the technology. If you are having problems with bond strength it is almost surely a problem in your process, such as inadequate cleaning or failure to remove scale, rather than a weakness in the selected technology. Further, you’re generally not free to simply substitute one process for the other anyway since there are many potential limitations to each process.

Please explain your situation. Casting a question in the abstract makes it difficult to actually help you. Thanks!

Regards,

Ted Mooney, finishing.com
Ted Mooney, P.E.
Striving to live Aloha

finishing.com – Pine Beach, New Jersey



Need quick confidential answers? $25
Need project assistance? $100/hr.

adv.
saify ind youtube