Could ashes from our bonfire have ruined the paint on neighbor's car?
A discussion started in 2009 but continuing through 2018August 25, 2009
Q. My family recently had a bon fire and the ashes from the fire traveled approximately 400 feet across the road and landed on the neighbors car. We will not deny that. However now the neighbors want their car repainted stating the ashes from the fire burned through their clear coat. Is this possible everyone that does body work says it's impossible. That the temperature of the ashes to burn the clear can't happen it's a 1998 gm car. They are known for clear coat issues especially for a car that sits outside year round. Thanks.Mike Deborde
- Xenia, Ohio, USA
August 25, 2009
A. Hi, Mike. It does sound unlikely that ashes could burn the paint on a car 400 foot away. The paint on your neighbor's 11-12 year old car is 11-12 years old; but maybe you can offer them their choice of a $199 paint job or a $199 detailing.
Ted Mooney, P.E.
Pine Beach, New Jersey
Striving to live "Aloha"
August 27, 2009
A. If the neighbors car doesn't have the factory paint on it they may be right. Have it buffed first, that might take care of the issue.
supply chain electronics
Wake Forest, North Carolina
September 6, 2009
A. No offense, but it sounds like your neighbor isn't the nicest person.
Unless they are threatening with legal action (and you get a summons or other documents from court and they get all quiet) I would suggest ignoring them.
There is a snowball's chance in death valley of any embers reaching their car 400 feet away and being hot enough to damage the clear coat.
Tell them to suck it up, realize that their car is 10 years old, the paint is 10 years old, and they need to dig into their own pockets to pay for it.
Blacksmith - Boone, North Carolina
September 9, 2009
Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
September 10, 2009
There are two possible cases to answer.
September 28, 2009
Q. We are going through this exact same battle with our neighbor. What was the outcome with yours?Alissa Kuder
- Crystal, Minnesota, USA
December 10, 2018
Q. My neighbor burns 300 ft 50 ft tall off-site garbage of all kinds from his rental and lawn business in his yard ... 25 ft from his house 75 from ours. Burning all kinds of crap for 4 years. City will do nothing even though he violates city and state code according to dept of natural resources; but they will not stop him.
He damaged my car paint on new car 2 times; our house paint and gutters our black; fills our house with nasty smell for days and little one got breathing problems; melted electrical wires -- we had no electric for 2 days; melted our electric meter replaced 2 times -- now has metal cover; melted our antenna, internet roof box and tv antenna; and lives next door to over 100 acres ... and 2 days later our yard covered in dead birds.
The house other side of him has a 500 l above-ground propane tank. Everyone scared of him as he is ex cop with guns and no one will do anything. If you call fire dept they put fire out, then he retaliates. Been 4 years, fires getting bigger; we all live in fear and city or state will do nothing they say until major damage or death accuses. Home owners says they can't fix because will just get damaged again ... have to wait for him to stop. We are sad, we have family in bad health that can't visit and children on bus so bus will not come down to pick our child up; same with hospital bus elderly on oxygen so they can't come down no more to pick my mom up for treatment -- just too much smoke from landscape trees, leaves, bad gas of clothes, furniture, tires, etc ... just miserable.Lewis M [last name deleted for privacy by Editor]
- Catawissa Missouri
^- Privately contact this inquirer -^
December 19, 2018
A. Hello Lewis, It's time to take this idiot to court and file suit. I can't believe that local authorities do nothing. Obviously you and your family are entitled to breathing decent air. As far as having to replace electric meters because of heat damage, that will also be part of your lawsuit.Mark Baker
Electronics plating - Phoenix Arizona USA
December 26, 2018
A. If the guy is bringing trash in his personal or business vehicles, to his residential-zoned property, which is not a transfer station or waste treatment facility, for the purpose of incineration/disposal, he's most likely violating a bunch of federal regulations- failing to register as a waste transporter, failing to register as a receiving facility, failure to use pollution prevention apparatus on a trash incinerator, the list goes on.
Both the DOT and the EPA would be involved in shutting him down and slapping him with fines that would make his head spin. I'll betcha he's got a few OSHA violations too, but your number one help is going to be the EPA. Here's a link to the EPA complaint submission for Region 7, email@example.com is the complaint email:
Here's the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, in case you think he's illegally transporting hazmat for disposal in a personal or non placarded business vehicle:
This type of situation has the potential to be EXTREMELY expensive for you to attempt to litigate privately as it will require professional air, water, and soil sampling that you'll have to pay for out of pocket, expert witnesses to interpret the results when and if it ends up in court, attorneys fees even if it doesn't, and if the guy isn't a corporation with assets, you might not see much of a settlement... and a win isn't guaranteed. Which is why you also could have a hard time finding someone to litigate it to begin with. The big environmental court cases you see in the news are mostly class-action lawsuits with multiple plaintiffs and big assets to grab as compensation- better odds for an attorney or firm to take a gamble. You won't likely see Broke Bubba the Backyard Burner getting slapped with a class action from the whole neighborhood. The best attorney STILL can't squeeze blood out of a turnip.
Luckily the EPA and DOT exist to make sure things don't get to that level. Your local authorities might not know what to do but you can be dead certain the EPA will have some ideas!
Document, document, document. Take photos when you can, be sure to document time/date, if you see him hauling 55 gallon drums, old paint cans, etc. in his truck, take photos and/or describe them, note if he does a large burn shortly afterwards. Just send your evidence to the feds. They will be the most direct in handling this type of mess. If they don't, and the guy gets away with it for years and then abandons the property, it gets very expensive for them, up to and possibly including Superfund/brown fields type remediation. So they absolutely want to make sure he's financially responsible for cleanup while he is still in legal possession of the property!
Plating Solutions Control Specialist / Industrial Metals Waste Treatment - Brattleboro, Vermont
If you have a question in mind which seems off topic, please Search the Site