Ultrasonic Agitation: Important Air Mixing Question

Summary for ultrasonic agitation Discussion

Ultrasonic agitation is the focus of this thread, where Phil Garrett asks whether air-agitating an acid cleaning solution before immersing parts could harm the later ultrasonic cleaning action. The excerpt does not include a full technical reply, but the question itself makes clear that the concern is whether pre-mixing with air agitation might negatively affect ultrasonic agitation properties or cleaning performance. No conflicting answers are shown in the provided text, and no named respondent’s advice is available in the excerpt beyond the questioner and location/date details. The practical issue for readers is whether solution mixing method matters when using ultrasonic cleaning in an acid bath, especially if air agitation is used only beforehand to keep the solution from settling.

Q. I am currently using ultrasonic agitation to clean different parts in an acid solution. In order to mix the solution and prevent laying I am mixing using air agitation

⇦ huh?
prior to submerging the parts, will this air agitation prior have any negative effect on the ultrasonic agitation properties?

Phil Garrett
Finisher – Nottingham UK
April 21, 2009


simultaneous replies

A. That should not be a problem. You might have a problem with the amount of acid in a micromist that is entrained in the air and carried out of the tank. You can always go to manual mixing or powered mechanical mixing prior to using the ultrasonics.

James Watts
– Navarre, Florida
April 27, 2009


Phil,
If you are using air agitation just for mixing for a brief time, then shutting it down, then I don’t see any problem. There are some acid based plating solutions that use continuous air agitation with no adverse affects other than a slight increase in evaporation rates.

Mark Baker
Fellow Plater – Syracuse, New York USA
April 28, 2009


April 28, 2009

Phil,

The negative effect you will find using that sequence of operations is potentially longer processing times. The use of air agitation will cause gases to dissolve in solution. Some of the energy of the ultrasonics will be transferred to these gases versus directly to the part. This could cause longer time in the acid to obtain the necessary cleaning action. If your parts are susceptible to hydrogen embrittlement, I would recommend holding in a rinse and allowing the ultrasonics to operate for 5-7 minutes to remove the dissolved gases.

Best of luck!

Ira Donovan, M.S.F.
Kansas City, Missouri

A. Ultrasonic agitation cleans largely by cavitation. I would not expect it to need any additional mixing except perhaps a gentle stir when making additions.
If you pass air through the solution you disrupt the ultrasonic path at every air bubble/solution interface and I would expect it to significantly decrease the efficiency of the bath.
Acids are rarely used for cleaning. If your actual use is removal of surface oxides, etc., I would not expect US to greatly improve the process. Simple immersion usually does the job as well, cheaper and a great deal quieter.

geoff smith
Geoff Smith
Hampshire, England
April 30, 2009