Anodic Hotspot in Center: Surprising but Useful Insight

Summary for anodic hotspot in center Discussion

Anodic points in the center of a nail can occur for reasons that are not always easy to pin down, according to the reply to Kim’s corrosion lab question. The student observed anodic spots at the tip, head, and middle of a nail in agar with phenolphthalein and potassium ferricyanide, and wondered why the center would behave that way when many sources mention only the ends. The answer says the exact cause probably does not matter for the lab observation: the center may have been straightened during manufacture, bent and reworked by a carpenter, or may simply have a slightly different material composition. The practical takeaway is that steel often gets phosphatized before painting partly to help deal with these unpredictable anodic hotspots. The response suggests noting this as an example of why corrosion behavior can be localized and difficult to control.

Q. I’m a grade twelve student doing a lab on the corrosion of iron. When I placed a nail in agar solution with phenolphthalein

⇦ on

eBay &

Amazon [affil link]
and potassium ferricyanide ⇦ on

eBay

orsit

Amazon

[affil link], I observed anodic points at the tip, head, and in the center of the nail. For the life of me, or anyone in the class, I cannot figure out why the center of the nail would act as an anodic point. I think it might be relevant only to our brand of nails, because I’ve read from many sources that anodic points form frequently on the head and tip. Can you help us?

Kim C. [last names of minors deleted]
student – New York City, New York, USA
2006

SUGGESTED PHOSPHATING BOOKS

phos_sharma22

“Optimization of Phosphating Process” by Vinod Prasad Sharma (2022)
avail from
<!–UTL eBay, –>
AbeBooks, or
Amazon

Image related to Flattening the ends of steel tubes leads to corrosion?

“Phosphating of Metals” by Werner Rausch (1991)
avail from
eBay,
AbeBooks, or
Amazon

phos_freeman1991

“Phosphating & Metal Pretreatment” by D.B. Freeman (1986)
avail from
eBay,
AbeBooks, or
Amazon

(as an Amazon Associate & eBay Partner, we earn from qualifying purchases)

A. Hi Kim, the truth is it probably doesn’t matter why there is an anodic hotspot in the center of the nail, there just is. It could be that the nail was straightened there during manufacture or after a carpenter bent it; or there could be a slightly different material composition there.

But for something to note in your report, you might say that one of the reasons steel is usually phosphatized before painting is to counteract this sometimes intractable problem of anodic hotspots.

Ted Mooney, finishing.com
Ted Mooney, P.E.
Striving to live Aloha

finishing.com – Pine Beach, New Jersey



Need quick confidential answers? $25
Need project assistance? $100/hr.