Lead Wastewater Treatment: Powerful Sulfide Fix for Limits

Summary for lead wastewater treatment Discussion

Wastewater treatment of lead is discussed in terms of whether calcium hydroxide alone can meet a very tight discharge limit. Kanwal Pradeep Kapur notes that the solubility graph for metal hydroxides suggests the lowest lead concentration is still about 5 mg/L at around pH 9.2, while the required limit is 0.05 ppm, and asks whether another chemical could replace Ca(OH)2. The answer recommends sulfide chemistry as a likely route to lower lead further, specifically suggesting bench tests with sodium sulfide, DTC, and TMT-15. If those reagents work, the responder says a polishing stage could be added after the calcium hydroxide treatment. The advice is practical but cautious, emphasizing that hands-on testing and assistance may be needed rather than relying on theory alone.

Q. Solubility of metal hydroxides graph indicates that the lowest point corresponds to lowest concentration of LEAD in treated water is where we have approximately 5 mgpl of LEAD at roughly 9.2 pH, whereas the statutory requirement is to bring it down to 0.05 ppm. Can you propose some way out like substituting some other chemical in place of Ca(OH)2 to tackle this situation.

KANWAL PRADEEP KAPUR
– CHITTORGARH, RAJASTHAN, INDIA
2005

A. Sulfide chemistry will probably do it. Do some bench tests with sodium sulfide, DTC, TMT-15. If they work, you could perhaps add a polishing stage after calcium hydroxide treatment. You may need hands-on assistance rather than an internet posting though :-)

Ted Mooney, finishing.com
Ted Mooney, P.E.
Striving to live Aloha

finishing.com – Pine Beach, New Jersey



Need quick confidential answers? $25
Need project assistance? $100/hr.

2005

A. Removing lead to < 0.05 mg/L is very difficult, and probably beyond what conventional treatment can achieve on a consistent basis. My experience is that 9.2-9.3 is the best pH, however, there may still be 0.1-0.3 mg/L of soluble lead present at this pH, and much more if there are any suspended solids present.

Most companies faced with this low limit will either use a chemical precipitant such as carbamate in combination with microfiltration, or use selective ion exchange to polish the effluent after conventional treatment.

Lyle Kirman
consultant – Cleveland Heights, Ohio
2005