topic 34107
Zinc-plate appearance problems (white, powdery, rough surface)
A discussion started in 2005 but continuing through 2018
2005Q. Came across parts after batch zinc-plating in acid-chloride that exhibit a white, powdery, streaky appearance (Parts are flat ~16 x 16 w/ moderate forming). When compared to "good" batches, "bad" batches seem rougher in texture (along with a overall lower reflectivity). Subsequent rubbing of the finished part surface with your hand exaggerates the powdery condition and leaves a white residue. You can clean off an area of a "bad" part with an acetone-soaked rag which removes the white residue and the zinc coating remains in tact.
It's questionable whether the substrate and/or plating process contains the key variables for this problem. Batch process utilizes two rounds of cleaning w/ de-ionized water and finally plating in a acid-chloride bath. Parts and finally a clear chromate conversion coating to passivate.
Anyone ever see this condition and have any ideas? Thought maybe surface roughness of the substrate and/or clear chromate was the culprit.
Thanks for the help.
Chris Tobinmetallurgist - Baltimore, Maryland
A. Hello Chris. You say you 'came across' these, which leaves us with the questions of whether they are new or old and whether you are working in the plating shop or these parts were shipped to you, etc. My first guess is it's boric acid. Some plating shops (low tech, non-spec work) will on occasion hang a bag of boric acid in a plating tank and almost immediately start plating, with result that crystals or powder form on the plated parts.
My second guess equals your first guess that it's a clear chromate problem.
Ted Mooney, P.E.
finishing.com
Pine Beach, New Jersey
Striving to live "Aloha"
2005
Q. Ted, thank you for the quick response. To help clarify my original inquiry, we are currently supplying low-carbon 1006/1008 CRSH to a customer who stamps parts and uses their own plater. Our customer and their plater are quite frustrated and I can understand they would want to question the substrate properties (ladle chem., rust-preventative oil, etc..). They've requested we be a main player in the analysis. I've begun working with their plater (via phone) to help them resolve and to this point have only received "good" and "bad" parts along with substrate ID(yet to do SEM/EDS on the powder). Info. gathered thus far leads me to believe there are more problems to worry about than the substrate.
Info gathered:
by Herb Geduld
from Abe Books
or
info on Amazon
-All supplied substrate is confirmed to be supplied with the same rust-preventative oil (Quaker Ferrocote 61).
-Supplied substrate is Al-killed 1006/1008 w/ very low residual Si and similar chemistry, however a few shipments had higher levels of Cu (.11% vs .05%). Would higher Cu levels in the steel makeup be an issue?
-Supplied substrate had surface profilometer values measured in microinches of ~30-50 which is seen as typical for most mills at the same gauge (.040"-.050"). Maybe higher surface roughness holds excess solutions/oils through cleaning/plating/chromating?
-Plater uses alkaline cleaning solution w/ two rounds of rinses and plates out a .0002 - .0005 flash zinc in acid chloride w/ a final trivalent coat(clear chromate).
-Plater reports that they will run a batch of parts that will exhibit this condition IMMEDIATELY AFTER THE PLATING PROCESS (apparently within seconds) and run another soon after, apparently under the same conditions with another batch of similar steel (same grade, etc..) without issues (nice bright, uniform zinc). Keep in mind I haven't determined if "immediately" means as soon as it comes out of the acid chloride tank or right after the chromate is applied (which I will obviously need to investigate). Could you help me understand the steps between plating and chromating and between chromating and finished product?
-There's apparently no handling involved, as the plater uses a circular rack which can hold ~80 of these parts at one time.
-The condition seen on these parts is strikingly similar to the bottom left photo of letter 18213, however, the entire surface seems to be very very light white in color (powdery and streaky with a rougher surface). It becomes even more exaggerated though when touched or rubbed with any applied pressure.
-The plater has been relying on what has been referred to as a "time-saver" which we are told is a belt-sander that is used on the steel prior to plating. This works well for them and is a large part why they are questioning substrate.
Being more process metallurgy oriented with only some electroplating knowledge (and knowing not to overstep my bounds), I'm looking for help from the finishing community to direct the right questions to the plater and help set up experiments to determine root cause.
Thanks again for the input
Chris Tobin [returning]metallurgist - Baltimore, Maryland
A. CAUSES FOR BURNED DEPOSIT,
1.IN THE ABSENCE OF ADDITION AGENTS,THE DEPOSITS ARE COARSE-GRAINED AND SHOW NO REFLECTIVITY,QUALITY IS VERY POOR AND MOST OF THE DEPOSIT CAN ACTUALLY BE RUBBED OFF BY APPLYING ONLY A LIGHT ABRASION.
2.LOW ZINC METAL CONTENT.
3.TOO HIGH CURRENT DENSITY.
4.LOW OPERATING TEMP.
5.LOW BORIC ACID.
ETC,.
ROUGHNESS:- EXCESSIVE ANODE SLUDGE,TORN ANODE BAGS. REDUCE AIR AGITATION NEAR ANODE BAGS.
Ludhiana, Punjab, India
February 12, 2013
Q. Hi All experts,
I'm facing blur and rough surface problem on my rack plating (some okay but most have blur and roughness problem).
I've checked the ph between 5 - 5.5 and the temperature is around 29 °C.
Please advise, Lovely thanks.
- Malaysia
July 5, 2013
Q. Good day,
I have a current customer complaint due to a surface finish on one of our part numbers that they define as "rusty". Before we ship the parts to our customer this condition is not present. Parts normal transportation is by sea (I go ignore if that is a factor for this "rust" to appear) but the customer claims that not all the parts have this condition so we would like to know what to look for at with our supplier that plates the part and focus on the factors that could produce these "physical appearance or rust". I appreciate your help.
- Tijuana, BC, Mexico
|
July 12, 2013 A. Dear Monica, - Cañuelas, Buenos Aires, Argentina July 12, 2013 A. Monica,  Feather Hollow Eng. Stockton, California |
July 15, 2013
Thank you very much!! I already started questioning this. I appreciate the feedback.
- Tijuana B.C. Mexico
May 29, 2014
Hello
I am a buyer and receiver. I don't have direct experience in plating. I order our parts to be plated with the following description: Zinc Chloride Clear Rack Lacquer .0002" meeting plating spec ASTM B633 - Type III Fe/Zn 5.
We have regular problems with white rust, streaking and drip marks that are visible when received from plater. See picture for most recent quality problem.
Is this a prep issue or a plating issue? Or chromate coating not done properly?
Paul Braden- Rockwood, Ontario, Canada
May 2014
A. Hi Paul. I'd categorize it as a vendor issue because parts that look like this should not be shipped to you :-)
I realize the temptation to want to understand the issue and your desire to explain to the vendor what they are doing wrong, but it's very difficult and probably not productive because they probably know a lot better than you and I what the problem is :-(
My guess is that improper drying or lack of drying is involved, based mostly on the second picture where we see marks that look like what you would get if the pipes were set down wet on cardboard or newspaper to dry (what we are seeing as the top would be the bottom as they dry). Although I'm reasonably confident that this is one problem, and that it can cause the white rust shown on the first photo, I'm far from confident that it is the only problem.
I would suggest that you decide what constitutes unacceptable appearance vs. what are acceptable minor cosmetic flaws, then agree with your plater about it, and even build "sample boards" of good & bad parts if necessary. Good luck.
Regards,
Ted Mooney, P.E.
finishing.com
Pine Beach, New Jersey
Striving to live "Aloha"
May 16, 2015
Q. Dear experts,
We are doing zinc plating (barrel plating) with trivalent white, hexavalent yellow passivation for our machined parts. After plating, these parts are packed in polythene bags and put inside cartons in a closed atmosphere. Some parts are not sold immediately were kept at our warehouse for one year. These parts were re inspected after one year and found passivation fade out and white patches. Please help to resolve the issue.
- Chennai, Tamilnadu, India
March 2017
Hi Dinesh. They probably weren't dry.
Regards,
Ted Mooney, P.E. RET
finishing.com
Pine Beach, New Jersey
Striving to live "Aloha"
March 29, 2017
Q. We are using zinc plated on ms steel cover in a timer switch in automobile industry. After a few operations some of the cases white residue starts formation inside the cover and moisture formed due to operational condition (heat raised around 60 °C in closed environment).
What's the problems in the zinc plating.
Please provide solution.
switches - Jharkhand,India
January 17, 2018
Q. I run an alkaline non-cyanide zinc electroplating line and we are having issues with white patches on our metal screws. Our plating solution is kept at 35 °C; our rinse tanks are cleaned regularly; and we use a trivalent blue chromate. Currently our caustic is at 142 g/l and our zinc is a 23 g/l
- Cincinnati ohio
February 27, 2019
Q. We are manufacturing brake parts. We do acid zinc plating but plated part in white powder, and plating color is yellow. I am not understanding this problem.
I think this problem is passivation, and how does it come with burning problems? Please explain this problem to me.
- Ahmedabad, Gujrat / india
February 2019
A. Hi Pintu. Please e-mail some good pictures of your problems to . It's hard to understand your description. Does the 'white powder' wash right off? Are the parts yellow before they go into the passivation bath? Are you sure you are operating a clear passivation bath, not a yellow one? I don't know what you mean 'how does it come with burning problems' -- are you saying the parts are burnt, or are you saying you don't quite know what burning is and looks like, so you don't know if they're burnt? Thanks.
Regards,
finishing.com
Pine Beach, New Jersey
Striving to live "Aloha"
If you have a question in mind which seems off topic, please Search the Site