Removing Rust from Medieval Sword: Safe, Smart Advice

Summary for removing rust from medieval sword Discussion

The thread on removing rust from medieval sword centers on a simple warning: if the blade is truly an antique, especially from the 1600s or earlier, most responders say not to try aggressive cleaning yourself. Goran Budija suggests a 5% citric acid solution, but Marc Banks, Allan Hmelnitski, and Joseph Podhorsky all caution that rubbing, sanding, wire brushing, or steel wool can permanently damage the sword and destroy its value. Marc Banks recommends leaving a real antique alone or taking it to a museum or other professional to arrest the rust. Allan Hmelnitski says to ask historical museum professionals what to do, and Joseph Podhorsky notes that a licensed sword professional may be able to help, though bright refinishing would likely be expensive. The practical consensus is to preserve the piece rather than polish it, and if a shiny blade is desired, buy a modern inexpensive one instead.

Q. I bought a vintage medieval sword and it is rusty and I would like to know how to take the rust off without damaging the sword thnx.

Joseph Kennedy
student – Waterloo, Belgium
2005

simultaneous replies

A. You can remove rust with naval jelly

⇦ on

eBay or
Amazon [affil link]
. After you remove the rust, you will probably find it dull and pitted where the rust was. Hours of rubbing with fine sandpaper and 00 steel wool

⇦ on

eBay or
Amazon [affil link] will make it look better.

jeffrey holmes
Jeffrey Holmes, CEF
Spartanburg, South Carolina

A. You can use 5% citric acid

⇦ on

eBay

or

Amazon [affil link] solution (or 50 gm citric acid /1 lit water/+add ammonia

⇦ on

eBay or
Amazon [affil link] to pH3,5)! Good luck!

Goran Budija
– Cerovski vrh Croatia

A. If you mean that this is an actual sword that is from the 1600’s or before I would suggest against doing anything to it aside from hanging it up on a wall and enjoying it. Antique swords are prone to rust unless they were well cared for over the years (lots of oiling and polishing). If you decide that you do want to have a bright finish on the sword, sell it and buy a 25 dollar blade rather than ruining an antique. If you decide that you do want to keep this sword, take it to a professional (i.e., museum) and have them arrest the rust.

Marc Banks
– Elizabeth City, North Carolina

A. Please, don’t rub it with files, sandpaper, wire brush, etc.! It makes it worthless! leave the real thing as it is. You can call to some historical museum, and ask professionals, what to do.
And buy another cheap Chinese glittering sword, if you want.

Allan Hmelnitski
– Tallinn, Harjumaa, Estonia
2005

A. If it is truly an authentic medieval sword, you should do nothing to it by yourself. A licensed sword professional might be able to do something with it, and if you want it to have a bright finish, it would most likely cost serious money. Whatever you do, do NOT use steel wool on your blade.

Joseph Podhorsky
– San Diego, California, USA.
2007


Q. Hi, I’m thinking about buying a sword made of spring steel. I want to know if that type of steel is susceptible to rust and requires maintenance and special care.

Andrew Colombus
buyer – Hungary
October 15, 2011


Microcrystalline
Museum Waxes

museum_wax

on Amazon or

eBay


(affil link)

A. Hi Andrew.
Yes, spring steel is very prone to rust. Keep it in a controlled environment (indoors) when not in use, and keep it well waxed or oiled.
Luck & Regards,

ted_yosem
Ted Mooney, P.E. RET
Striving to live Aloha

finishing.com – Pine Beach, New Jersey



Need quick confidential answers? $25
Need project assistance? $100/hr.