Summary for hydrobromic acid electroless nickel Discussion
Hydrobromic acid corrosion resistance data for electroless nickel is the central question, and the thread says no direct published data was found. David Sugg asked whether anyone knew of data for 9% hydrobromic acid in oil at 120-140°F on electroless nickel. James Watts replied that hydrobromic acid sits chemically between hydrofluoric and hydrochloric acid, so a high-phosphorus EN coating might possibly be used, but he urged checking with the EN vendor and warned that the elevated temperature makes eventual failure likely; he said long-term lab testing is the only rational way to verify performance and suggested considering stainless steel instead of plating. Sugg agreed that high-phosphorus EN seemed the best bet but likely would still be attacked over time. A later answer added that pure nickel is rapidly attacked by hydrobromic acid at room temperature, with corrosion rates over 50 mpy, and expected EN to behave similarly or worse at 120°F.
Q. A customer contacted me today looking for corrosion resistance data for the affect of Hydrobromic Acid (9% concentration in oil, at
120-140°F)on Electroless Nickel. I have checked all the standard references and have not found any data. Is anyone aware of any data on Hydrobromic Acid on Electroless Nickel? Any help greatly appreciated.
David Sugg
Plating Shop – Collingdale, Pennsylvania, USA
2004
A. Hydrobromic acid is midway between hydrofluoric acid and hydrochloric acid. So, you might get away wit EN coating it if you use a high P EN. Check with your EN vendor for their comments. The upper temperature that you mention would make me inclined to predict eventual failure. Lab testing is probably the only rational way to check, and that would be long term testing. I would look at an appropriate stainless steel and not plate.
James Watts
– Navarre, Florida
2004
A. James,
Thanks for your comments. I was guessing that Hydrobromic would be slightly less corrosive than Hydrochloric, since it is below it on the Periodic Chart. Otherwise, my thoughts are similar to yours in that I think High Phosphorus Electroless Nickel has the best probability of standing up, but even it will likely be attacked over time.
Again, thanks for your comments.
David Sugg
– Collingdale, Pennsylvania, USA
2004
A. There is no data that I know of on the corrosion of EN in hydrobromic acid. However, pure nickel is very rapidly attacked by hydrobromic acid at all concentrations at room temperature. According to the Corrosion Data Survey, its corrosion rate is greater than 50 mils per year. I would expect that EN would be attacked at about the same rate at room temperature and at much higher rates at 120 °F.

Ron Duncan [deceased]
– LaVergne, Tennessee
It is our sad duty to note Ron’s passing on Dec. 15, 2006. A brief obituary opens
Episode 13 of our Podcast.