Summary for electroless nickel wear Discussion
electroless nickel for sliding wear is the main recommendation in this thread, with several responders saying hardcoat anodize is a poor choice for this kind of service. Jeffrey A. Cuenin asked for a coating that could survive 24/7 shuffling cardboard on 7075-T6 aluminum after hardcoat anodize .003" failed in three weeks on a sandblasted surface. Todd Osmolski said electroless nickel around 60 Rc usually outlasts hardcoat in sliding applications and can be stripped and replated without harming the aluminum. James Watts suggested 0.005" hard chrome, while noting that something besides simple abrasion may be causing the rapid failure. Lee Gearhart advised that hardcoat works best when done cold and on a smoother surface, and mentioned a possible Teflon topcoat. Dan Weaver recommended electroless nickel with codeposited silicon carbide as the best plated finish. Bill Ferree proposed thermal-sprayed tungsten carbide with cobalt or nickel matrix, also noting the low friction, but agreed the failure may involve more than wear alone.
Q. I HAVE ALUMINUM VACUUM PLATES THAT REQUIRE AN EXTREMELY HARD WEAR SURFACE. TRIED HARD COAT ANODIZE .003 THICK BUT IT FAILED IN 3 WEEKS. SURFACE IS SAND BLASTED FOR ROUGHNESS. PLEASE ADVISE OF ANY PLATING OR COATING PROCESS THAT WOULD SURVIVE THE HARSH CONDITIONS OF SHUFFLING CARDBOARD 24/7 MATERIAL IS 7075 T6.
JEFFREY A CUENIN
– LANCASTER, NEW YORK, USA
2003
A. Electroless Nickel with a 60 RC hardness usually outlasts Hardcoat in sliding applications. Hardcoat is hard but it has terrible lubricity or sliding wear.Electroless nickel can also be stripped and replated on aluminum parts without damaging the aluminum.
Todd Osmolski
– Charlotte, North Carolina, USA
2003
That ‘stripped and replated’ point is well taken, Todd. Thanks.
Ted Mooney, P.E.
Striving to live Aloha
finishing.com – Pine Beach, New Jersey
Need quick confidential answers? $25
Need project assistance? $100/hr.
2003
 | A. I would try 0.005 of hard chrome plate. There has to be some other factor besides abrasion to wear out 0.003 of hard coat in 3 weeks. I do not think that a coating of 0.0015 of EN would last any better than the hard coat. James Watts A. Electroless nickel plating may be the coating of choice. I suggest low phosphorus type. hardness as plated can be 700 Knoop, 100 gm load.
|
| A. After talking with you and neglecting to get your phone number I thought up some other trials. We talked about being sure the hard coat was done at about 32 °F for maximum hardness. We also discussed the fact that the crystal builds perpendicular to the surface and that on micro curved surfaces such as you would have with a rough sand blast, the crystals would build up to a certain thickness and then crash into and break off each other. You were going to try a smoother starting finish so that the crystals will build straight out and not crash. In the 1960’s NASA in Huntsville developed a method for occluding diamond dust in the oxide. I have a source for a teflon top coat that might slip the cardboard by without wearing.
2003 A. Jeffrey, did you anodize first and then sandblast for roughness? The anodize may have heartburn with sandblasting as the substrate may not support it- depends on the intensity. Does the plate have to be aluminum? Chromium plated steel works in a wide variety of wear applications. If you want a hard, rough surface, have you considered thermal spraying? An HVOF coating of tungsten carbide is everyday technology, readily available, and may do what you need. Good luck!
|
“The Surface
Treatment &
Finishing of
Aluminium and
Its Alloys”
by Wernick, Pinner
& Sheasby
on Amazon
or
or
(affil link)
A. Thought I would put my two cents worth in this brainstorming session. EN is better than hardcoat for sliding wear. The best plated finish IMHO would be EN/codeposited silicon carbide. We did a plastic injection mold one time that had to be modified after plating was completed. The mold maker told me he had worn out diamond tooling trying to grind the finish.
Dan Weaver
– Toccoa, Georgia
2003
A. This is routine procedure for us (we are a thermal spray company). Simply coat the affected area with tungsten carbide with either a cobalt or nickel matrix – typical hardness is around 70 Rc with extremely low coefficients of friction. However, I agree with one responder that something other than wear must be affecting the surface to achieve so quick a failure?
Bill Ferree
– Houston, Texas
2003