Spotwelds and Rust: A Clear Warning for Bare Steel

Summary for spotwelds and rust Discussion

spotwelds and rust are discussed in the context of a steel/Incoloy 825 spotweld assembly that showed heavy rust leaks after only 3 hours in water. Mario Lepire asked whether the spotweld itself caused the steel to rust so quickly and suspected crevice corrosion. The reply says the exact corrosion mechanism cannot be determined from the description, and it could involve crevice corrosion, galvanic corrosion, or capillary action drawing water into the joint and letting it leak out and stain. However, the key practical point is that the bare steel should not be expected to resist corrosion on its own: the response emphasizes that bare steel has essentially no corrosion resistance and needs a rust preventative unless it is plated or painted immediately. So the spotweld may have created a vulnerable crevice, but the rapid rusting is also consistent with unprotected steel exposure.

February 17, 2015

Q. Hi,

We have a common spotweld assembly of 2 small plates, one a common steel and the other is oncology 825. We had to rework some units with this spotweld assembly. To test another part of the total assembly, we had to put them in water for 3 hours. Nothing but water is in this container. Then several units have big rust leaks around the spotweld area.

I think it’s from the spotweld itself but I would like to know how the spotweld affected the steel to have rust after only 3 hours in the water. I guess there’s crevice rust involved in there.

thank you,

Mario

Mario Lepire
– Canada


Hi Mario. I’m thinking that your spell-check program substituted oncology for Incoloy?

I am not a corrosion theoretician and can’t tell you whether crevice corrosion vs. galvanic corrosion or other corrosion modes are involved. Capillary action will draw water up into the crevice, and it will leak out and stain. But we should not see the corrosion of bare steel in 3 hours as a quirky phenomena. Rather, we must realize that bare steel has essentially NO corrosion resistance and requires some sort of rust preventative if it is not to be plated or painted immediately. Good luck.

Regards,

Ted Mooney, finishing.com
Ted Mooney, P.E.
Striving to live Aloha

finishing.com – Pine Beach, New Jersey



Need quick confidential answers? $25
Need project assistance? $100/hr.

February 2015