Summary for rust bluing problem Discussion
Rust bluing problem: the work turns brown instead of black after boiling because, as Rod Henrickson explains, the solution being used is producing ferric oxide (Fe2O3), which is reddish brown, rather than magnetite (Fe3O4), which is black. The questioner, Amer Khalil, described making a solution from nitric acid and hydrochloric acid, applying it to a handgun barrel, and seeing brown rust form; after boiling, the part stayed brown/bronze instead of turning black. Henrickson says the chemistry is wrong for rust bluing and that a different solution is needed to form the black oxide. He also points to a Stackpole book, Firearm Blueing and Browning, as a reference for the process.
Q. Hi everyone, I have been trying to blue a handgun barrel as an experiment. I made a solution from HNO3 and HCl. After applying this solution, a thin layer of brown rust forms within an hour and a good one after 12 hours. Now when I put the piece into boiling water it turns brown/bronze in colour. Why not black?
Amazingly when I clean the piece and re-apply the solution, it turns dark gray after a while without boiling. Can anyone help explain what is going on actually?
Amer Khalil
Hobbyist – Peshawar, KPK, Pakistan
A. You are creating Fe203 which is ferric oxide, which is reddish brown. You want to make Fe3O4 which is magnetite which is black. Its a different solution. There is a book sold by stackpole called Firearm Blueing and Browning ⇦ on
eBay or
Amazon or
[affil links] by RH Angier. It has several of the formulas for slow process bluing. It’s sort of redundant in North America as a lot of the chemicals used are now very tightly controlled and no longer available.
Rod Henrickson
gunsmith – Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
November 29, 2012