Summary for copper corrosion from clear chromate Discussion
Copper corrosion from clear chromate is the issue raised by a thermal solutions company whose liquid cold plates were returned from a MIL-DTL-5541F Type II, Class 1A clear conversion coat process looking badly attacked: the copper tubing had turned reddish, some areas black, and in places the tubing appeared recessed about .005". The poster said earlier lots had always come back looking fine and asked whether anyone had seen copper react this way or knew why it happened. No answer text is included in the excerpt, so the thread source here only documents the problem and the concern that an unusual process variation or contamination may have caused the damage. The key takeaway from the question is that the finish should not normally produce this kind of visible copper attack, and the lot appears to have been processed differently from prior successful runs.
Q. We are a Thermal Solutions company that make liquid cold plates for the electronics industries. We have a product that went out for “Chemical Conversion Coat per MIL-DTL-5541F, Type II, Class 1A, Clear”. We have had the parts processed many times and they have come back without fail. They have looked great. But this current lot has come back completely different. The copper tube has almost turned to a reddish color. On some plates, the tubing has actually turned black and has recessed into the plate about .005″. I have never seen copper react like this for a clear chromate process. They grey substance you see is a thermal compound. Has anybody ever seen a reaction like this? Any ideas why something like this may have happened? Thank you for your help in advance!

Rob McCarter