Summary for thermocouples and controllers calibration Discussion
Thermocouples and controllers calibration is the central issue in this thread, where Ken Tolbert asks whether bath temperature control can be ignored because plating quality can supposedly be checked later by X-ray or other methods. The answerer says that while it is possible to overdo calibration, skipping it entirely is not wise. In his view, a simple weekly check with a thermometer may be enough for some operations, but relying on downstream defects to reveal bad temperature control is "silly." He argues that bath temperature still matters and should not be dismissed just because another inspection method exists. The response uses a blunt analogy to stress that preventive checks are better than waiting for failures to show up. Overall, the discussion supports at least some routine verification of thermocouples and controllers rather than treating calibration as unnecessary.
Q. It was recently stated to me that bath temps don’t affect the plating quality in such a way that cannot be detected in another manner (xray for example) and therefore it was decided that calibrations on the Thermocouples and Controllers was unnecessary.
Would this be a fair statement or is it in error?
Ken Tolbert
QE – East Bridgewater, Massachusetts
August 9, 2012
A. Hi Ken.
It is possible to overdo anything, including calibration. A quick dip of a thermometer into a tank once a week may be adequate.
But to skip it, believing it will be caught later is, in my opinion silly. It’s not much different than claiming that propylactics don’t have to be inspected for holes because you’ll soon get reports of STDs or pregnancies if there are any :-)
Regards,

Ted Mooney, P.E.
Striving to live Aloha
finishing.com – Pine Beach, New Jersey
Need quick confidential answers? $25
Need project assistance? $100/hr.
August 10, 2012