Bright Finish Nails Rust? Surprising Low-Cost Protection

Summary for bright finish nails rust Discussion

Bright finish nails are not usually rust-proof from a special coating; the key reason they survive in the box is that the wire is drawn with lubricants such as fats or waxes, and some of that residue remains on the nails to give limited corrosion protection. In this thread, Josh Malone asks why ordinary hardware-store nails can sit for years without rusting and whether a similar low-cost approach could protect a low-carbon-steel dowel pin without plating. The answer, attributed to Ted Mooney, P.E., explains that the remaining drawing lubricant provides only a little protection, but it is enough for storage conditions. He suggests that the dowel pins could be dipped in a bulk dry-to-touch rust preventive as a practical alternative. The discussion implies that a simple temporary preservative may be the closest low-budget substitute for plating, rather than expecting bare steel to behave like a plated part.

Q. We are producing a small dowel pin from low carbon steel and there is not enough budget to plate it for corrosion protection. If we can achieve the same quality of a typical “bright finish” nail found at any hardware store, then we are in good shape. Anyone know why these nails don’t rust in the box on the shelf? Even in stored in my garage they are good for 10 years or more.

Josh Malone
Product Designer – Plano, Texas, U.S.
October 25, 2010

WD-40 in bulk

wd_40

on Amazon or

eBay


(affil link)

A. Hi, Josh. Your garage must be nicer than my house  🙂

It is true that bright nails don’t rust in the benign environment of air conditioned stores if the stock keeps moving . . . but 10 years in your garage? I’d say a year or so in mine. I’d guess they have a a thin organic preservative, something along the lines of WD-40, but I don’t know and would be interested in learning about it myself. They are manufactured in accord with ASTM specs and those specs may say something about it.

Regards,

Ted Mooney, finishing.com
Ted Mooney, P.E.
Striving to live Aloha

finishing.com – Pine Beach, New Jersey



Need quick confidential answers? $25
Need project assistance? $100/hr.

A. The wire from which nails are made is drawn to size using drawing lubricant, some combination of fats/waxes. Some of that remains on the nails and offers a little corrosion protection.

Your dowel pins could be dipped in bulk in a dry-to-touch rust preventive.

jeffrey holmes
Jeffrey Holmes, CEF
Spartanburg, South Carolina