Hot Dip Galvanizing vs Electroplating: Smart Test Method

Summary for hot dip galvanizing vs electroplating Discussion

hot dip galvanizing vs electroplating is usually distinguished by coating thickness and appearance rather than a special standard test. Dr. R.V. Raghavendra asked whether there is a standard method to confirm which zinc coating is present. Dr. Thomas H. Cook replied that hot dip galvanizing after fabrication is virtually always thicker than 2 mils (about 51 microns), while electroplated zinc is usually only a few tenths of a mil, so a simple magnetic thickness gauge can normally tell them apart. Salah Salman added that electroplating is typically brighter and smoother, while hot dip coatings are less smooth; he also noted that continuous hot dip galvanizing can be thin, around 10-25 microns, so appearance alone is not enough. In a later question, Deepak Gupta asked whether 51 microns versus 85 microns affects strength, and the reply explained that galvanizing does not increase steel strength; it is for corrosion protection, and service life generally rises with coating thickness.

Q. As a testing laboratory, we are often asked to confirm whether the zinc coating present in samples is by hot dip galvanizing or electroplating. Are there any standard method to identify and confirm the same?

Regards,

Dr.R.V.Raghavendra
Geological and metallurgical LaboratoriesTesting laboratory – Bangalore, Karnataka, India
2006

A. Sir:
Because hot dip galvanizing (after fabrication) is virtually alway thicker than 2 mils (e.g. more than 51 microns) and electroplate zinc is almost always a thin coating (e.g. a few tenths of a mill), a simple “banana” magnetic thickness gauge can normally differentiate between hot dip and electroplate zinc.
Regards,

Dr. Thomas H. Cook

Galvanizing Consultant – Hot Springs, South Dakota, USA
2006

A. Dear All:
Peace be upon you,
It can differentiate between hot dip galvanizing and electroplating easily by visual, where electroplating is brighter and smoothly than hot dip one.
Moreover, the thickness of coating usually thin especially in continuouss hot dip galvanizing (10-25 micron, less than 1 mil).
Best Regards,

Salah Salman
Kama Coating – Cairo, Egypt


What makes the difference if make a hot dip product with 51 microns & one with 85 microns. Does it affect the strength of the product.

Deepak Gupta
hobby as well as business – Delhi, India
April 15, 2008

A. Hi, Deepak. Galvanizing is not applied to increase the strength of steel, and it doesn’t. It is applied to deter corrosion, and the anticipated service life is approximately proportional to the thickness of the zinc coating.

Regards,

Ted Mooney, finishing.com
Ted Mooney, P.E.
Striving to live Aloha

finishing.com – Pine Beach, New Jersey



Need quick confidential answers? $25
Need project assistance? $100/hr.

none

adv.
this text gets replaced with bannerText

spacer gets replaced with bannerImages