Chem Film vs Phosphate Wash: Strong Powder Coat Prep

Summary for chem film vs phosphate wash Discussion

Chem film vs. phosphate wash is presented as a practical question about aluminum pretreatment before powder coating, especially whether a chem film step is necessary in a sheet metal fabrication line and whether phosphate wash alone can provide reliable adhesion. Fred Brown asks for research or chemical references comparing the two and for any adverse adhesion experience with phosphate-only prep. James Watts replies that both methods are acceptable, but says the “best” choice depends heavily on the operator or company doing the work and on what criterion matters most. He notes that the decision can hinge on corrosion resistance, adhesion, speed, cost, abuse level, and storage conditions. The thread does not identify one universally superior process; instead, it frames the choice as application- and process-dependent rather than absolute.

Q. Is there a research or chemical reference for the properties of chem film vs. phosphate wash for prep of aluminum and resulting adhesion qualities of the powder coat to the aluminum? Is one better than the other? If so, which is best and why?

We have a powder coat line in our sheet metal fabrication plant and have been asked if the chem film step is necessary. I’d also appreciate knowing if anyone has any adverse experience with lack of adhesion using just a phosphate wash for prep of aluminum prior to powder coating.

Thanks.

Fred Brown
L&M Precision Fabrication, Inc. – Washington, USA
2005

A. Both methods are acceptable. Unfortunately, which one is best is rather dependent on which operator/company is doing the work.
Then, you get into “best” from what standpoint. Added corrosion resistance, adhesion, speed, cost, level of abuse and storage among others.

James Watts
– Navarre, Florida
2005