The finishing.com Hotline: Serious Education ... plus the most fun you can have in metal finishing. Ted Mooney, Webmaster
How to remove silica scale from faucets, etc.
Q. I am looking for a non-abrasive method to remove silica build up on faucets, shower heads, etc.Mark Schanfein
homeowner - Los Alamos, New Mexico
A. Commercial products like Lime Away and CLR are made for the purpose or removing build-ups, Mark. If they are ineffectual, my suspicion is that the problem is actually pitting in the underlying zinc die castings. That can't be fixed.
Ted Mooney, P.E. RET
Pine Beach, New Jersey
Thanks for the feedback, indeed Lime and CLR do not work, and the white build up I am talking about is on the plastic shower nozzle and the interior glass surfaces of the shower stall. Our water analysis shows high concentrations of silica. Is there a chemical approach to remove this type of scale?
- Los Alamos, New Mexico, USA
A. Those cleaners are essentially organic acids for removing carbonates of calcium and magnesium. They won't remove silica, which is itself acid (at least chemically, although it's not corrosive-type acid).
Just because the water has a high silica content, does that necessarily mean the deposits are silica? Maybe it's just soap scum that will come off with an alkaline cleaner?
Ballarat, Victoria, Australia
We sadly relate the news that Bill passed away on Jan. 29, 2010.
A. You might try cleaning it with a solution of 2 -4 tablespoons of bicarb of soda in hot water, followed by a rinse followed by straight white vinegar. Repeat two or three cycles and see if anything happens. Scotch brite, even fine ones will probably scratch the plating.James Watts
- Navarre, Florida
Q. Actually, my public works department said to try Lime Away and CLR and if that did not take it off, it confirmed it is silica. Definitely not soap scum, especially on the shower head. It is also building up on the glass shower door. I can scrape it off with a razor blade. That is not a practical approach for a showerhead that is made out of plastic with the water slots filling up with the deposits and so the desire for a chemical approach. It looks like there is not one from the responses so far.Mark Schanfein
- Los Alamos, New Mexico, USA
A. I have the same issue and have tried EVERY product that there is without success until I found this one. It is called A-maz =>
- salem oregon usa
A. We've had the same problem and found a product called Spot X [link is to product info & reviews at Amazon] that works beautifully. Also, as far as the showerhead, CLR [linked by editor to product info at Amazon] will do the trick but you must soak the part in full strength CLR for 24 hours or so. Hope this helps.Eddie Cruey
- Davidson, North Carolina
November 27, 2008
A. Mark from Los Alamos is right about the high silica content in our water. I live nearby and have the same problem with these white-ish spots on my shower door. I had the water tested and confirmed my water had unusually high silica levels. I have tried all the usual remedies but the one that did work and removed over 8 years of silica deposits is A-maz.
I used a Black & Decker mouse =>
- Santa Fe, New Mexico, USA
April 30, 2016
A. The white spots on the bathroom fixtures, sinks, shower doors, shower heads are indeed silica! CLR (Calcium-Lime-Rust) will not remove them! Razor blades or steel wool, or Scotch Brite pads (mechanical operations) will remove the silica -but scratch them in the process. About 30 years ago, we were able to buy a glass cleaner at our local hardware store (I think it was called 'Sparkle' at the time - not the stuff called Sparkle now) that was dilute hydrofluoric acid (on the label) and would remove the subject spots. I've tried to buy hydrofluoric acid via internet vendors - but the ones that I have tried will not sell to a residential address, even though I run a technical business out of my house/garage/lab.Louis Rosocha, PhD
Applied Physics Consulting, LLC - Los Alamos, New Mexico