Serious Education ... plus the most fun you can have in metal finishing.
Trivalent Chrome Plating
A discussion started in 2004 and continuing through 2017 . . .(2004)
Q. I would like to know the basics about trivalent chromium plating as replacement for hex chrome, where can I get technical info and who's chemistry is considered to be the best, is the equipment somewhat different, do I need ion exchange, costs, advantages, disadvantages, etc.
I've heard some horror stories about premature corrosion and flaking of deposit and would really like to skip non reliable processes.
plating shop - Lerma, Edo Mex, Mexico
Ed. note: We can't get into debates about which proprietary process is best; but Chevy Truck / Ford Truck debates can get silly anyway. All of the major suppliers offer trivalent chromium plating including Atotech and Macdermid Inc. [a finishing.com supporting advertiser], and many plating shop managers firmly believe that by far the most important thing when making a choice between proprietaries is the expertise & dedication of the local tech service person :-)
A. Trivalent chrome is susceptible to salt attack.
We use trivalent for our decorative chrome and it bears up well with plenty if nickel underneath it. But we won't do marine pieces and have seen many failures where trivalent has been exposed to north eastern road salts.
Trivalent will not tolerate the wear of hex chrome either.
So it's horses for courses.
If your work pieces are decorative, trivalent is fine. If it is subject to salts or wear, use hex.Steve Clark
polishing shop - Belfast, Maine
First of two simultaneous responses -- (2004)
A. Trivalent chromium is good as a decorative finish but not very good as an engineering coating. It is slightly darker and greyer than hexavalent chromium and its colour is more varied. This can present problems when trying to assemble multiple parts into one assembly. The technology for trivalent plating is continuously advancing, so it would be best to talk to reputable suppliers about what you need and whta they can supply. When it first became available it was quite difficult to use and at least one process required a divided cell with a membrane separating the anode and cathode to prevent the anode oxidising the Cr(III) to Cr(VI). However, things have improved since then! As far as I am aware, there is no barrel plating trivalent system commercially available, but if a supplier has now got a reliable one, no doubt I will be corrected.
At the end of the day, you have to decide what you what and whether a supplier can meet your needs - its all "horses for courses".
R&D practical scientist
Chesham, Bucks, UK
Second of two simultaneous responses -- (2004)
A. We have been using trivalent chrome to plate Class 8 truck bumpers and grille surrounds for approximately 10 years. We have never had any problems with chipping or any particular abrasion problems. The classic problems you might experience with trivalent chrome as opposed to hex is that trivalent typically has a different color compared to hex and it is more susceptible to metallic contamination.
Depending on your rinsing, metallic contamination can be considerable. Speaking from personal experience, nickel and iron contamination can be very detrimental and cause big problems with color. Most suppliers recommend a small ion exchange system to remove metallics. If you have superior rinsing, it may not be required.
Trivalent tends to scratch and abrade more easily than hex so care must be taken in not being too aggressive when cleaning the finished parts. Some people will use abrasive waxes on hex chrome or even chrome buff. You should avoid the use of them when plating with Tri.
Conversely, trivalent doesn't have the problems of burning, whitewash and toxicity problems that hex has. You don't have to worry about a Chromic Acid/Sulfuric Acid ratio.
The chemical constituents are much more expensive with tri than hex. But, the overall reduction in wastewater costs, regulatory compliance and health and safety cost avoidance may help make up the difference. Hope this helps!
- Greenbrier, Tennessee
March 26, 2011 -- this entry appended to this thread by editor in lieu of spawning a duplicative thread
Q. dear all:
trivalent chromium plating gets darker coating compared with hex. is there any commercial products make the color as white as the hex?
student - China
March 28, 2011
A. Hi, YF.
Asif Nurie makes the point in letter 34810 that we really shouldn't judge today's trivalent chrome plating processes by the weaknesses of the processes of 25 years ago. Perhaps you should contact a few suppliers for their take on whether whiter trivalent chromium plating is available today. Good luck.
Ted Mooney, P.E. RET
Pine Beach, New Jersey
June 17, 2013
Q. What is the finish difference in Hex. Chrome plating & Tri-chrome plating on @ 15 microns of nickel (single layer) as an undercoat on finely finished mild steel parts? Is the trivalent colour exactly same as Hex. Chrome ( Bluish finish?) .
What is the CASS or Salt spray that we can achieve on Tri-chrome and compared with Hex chrome?
Which chemistry -- Sulphate bath or Mixed Bath performs better in terms of Neutral salt spray or CASS Test (without sealant, considering both plated on same type of Mild steel components with single layer nickel)?
- Vadodara, Gujarat, India
Passivation of dark trivalent chromium platingFebruary 9, 2017
Q. We are plating dark trivalent chromium on to both satin and bright nickel. We are having an issue where, some weeks after plating, the surface begins to change colour and look "aged" (for want of a better word).
There has been some discussion among management in our company (plating is not our primary activity, but we have a captive shop), but without any real plating experience among most of the management team, it has been inconclusive.
Unfortunately, even different people from our supplier seem to be giving us different information, so I thought I'd try getting some feedback from here:
Should we be using a passivate after dark trivalent chromium plating, and what effects are we likely to notice. Will it change the colour of the deposit, or will it prevent it from changing after plating?
Plating shop supervisor` - Brisbane, Qld, Australia