Letter 12048

Which water treatment type for metal finishing? 

Happy Holidays all you M-F's out there!(c'mon - metal finisher's - take it easy!!) I need advice once again. We are a large anodizing job shop interested in installing either D.I., R.O., loose R.O. or nanofiltration for our rinsewaters. Does anybody have experience or knowledge of which system works the best in metal finishing operations? Thanks.

Vic Waldman
- Naugatuck,CT.

I'm not a Monday to Friday'er--don't know what you mean.

I've never heard the term 'loose R.O.' I'm afraid.

But I don't believe there is any equivalence between the other three. Nanofiltration would be used after chemical precipitation to remove the solids, as an alternative to a clarifier (or direct filtration). R.O. is used for recovery, but to my knowledge does not generate a pure enough permeate for discharge. D.I. is not exactly a treatment strategy, it's more of a concentration strategy where the waste collects in the D.I. resin for later treatment.

But to compare D.I. vs. R.O. as concentration strategies, D.I. has a huge advantage in not being highly flow dependant (you can pass a relatively huge amount of dilute waste through a D.I. column at very low cost), but R.O. has the advantage of concentrating the waste without adding any more chemicals.

 
Ted Mooney, P.E.
finishing.com Inc. - Brick, NJ

I want to post a question or inquiry of my own.

 

I want to answer or follow-up on this question publicly (in non-commercial fashion).

 

I am a supporting advertiser and want to reach the inquirer privately.