Letter 1072

Recognized Standards for Electropolishing?

---

Can anyone tell me if there are any governmental standards in existence for electropolishing. I'm also interested in standard finishes for stainless steel, such as a standard which defines a #3 grain or #4 grain surface finish. We are looking for a way to reference standards on our internal documents to provide a better means of quality control. If you know of anything, could you please let me know. We are looking for standards that can be universally recognized by our suppliers (ANSI, ASME, etc.). Any help would be greatly appreciated.

Larry Dennis

Dear Larry,

There are currently no Mil-Specs for Electropolish. One reason for this is the process is very reliant on the type of material, the size, configuration, and finish of the material.

If you would like to discuss this further . . .

Thanks,

Dave Mortenson
Oakland, CA

Larry Dennis:

The only specifications we are aware of at this time are ASTM A-967 [link is to info about spec at TechStreet]-96 and those published by SEMI of Austin, TX. Both ASTM and SEMI can be reached at their respective web sites, astm.org and semi.org.

We would be pleased to assist you if further information is needed.

Regards,

Ed Bayha Metal Coating Process Corporation Charlotte, North Carolina, USA

Larry,

Each mill has their own definitions of what these finishes are. The Specialty Steel Industry of North America has a booklet on finishes of stainless steel. They are in the process of updating this publication and the revised publication won't be ready until end of this year.

You may want to visit them at http://www.ssina.com and request for a free copy of the booklet.

Any polishing technology whether electropolished, CMP or mechanical polishing requires that the starting substrate is of the best possible material to start with. Without such, the polishing can still result in "pin holes", "pits", "angel hairs". Some of these are starting defects with the sheets.

Sincerely,

Michael Liu Taylor    specialty stainless steel distributor Dallas, Texas

I want to answer or follow-up on this subject publicly

 

I want to post a new question or inquiry of my own on a different subject

 

This letter is within a monitored forum, very much "alive" here in 2008. If you spot any broken links or obsolete info, please advise!